What is a Guardian Ad Litem?

In New York family law cases, disputes involving custody, visitation, or guardianship can be emotionally charged and complicated. When a child’s interests may be at risk or not fully represented, the court can appoint a Guardian ad Litem (GAL) to step in as an impartial advocate. A GAL conducts an independent investigation and offers recommendations to help the court make decisions that support the child’s safety, stability, and overall well-being. Their role is especially important in high-conflict cases or when concerns about neglect, abuse, or parental fitness arise.

If you’re facing a custody battle, adoption, or guardianship matter in New York and want to better understand how a Guardian ad Litem could affect your case, speaking with a trusted Manhattan family law attorney may help. The Law Office of Richard Roman Shum, Esq., PLLC offers guidance tailored to your specific situation. Call (646) 259-3416 to schedule a consultation and get the support you need during this important legal process.

Role and Purpose of a Guardian ad Litem in New York

A Guardian ad Litem (GAL), Latin for “guardian for the suit”, is a court-appointed individual who represents the best interests of a child or an incapacitated person during the course of legal proceedings. This appointment is typically made in cases involving custody, visitation, guardianship, or other sensitive family law matters where the child’s welfare may be at risk or not adequately represented through the standard adversarial legal process.

The GAL serves as a neutral party. Their role is not to align with either side, but to offer the court an unbiased, well-informed perspective on what would most benefit the child. The GAL’s focus is on the child’s needs and interests, considering emotional, physical, and psychological well-being, regardless of the desires or positions of the parents involved in the case.

Who Can Be Appointed as a Guardian ad Litem in New York?

In New York, a Guardian ad Litem (GAL) must meet specific criteria to be eligible for appointment. While most GALs are practicing attorneys, the law also allows qualified non-attorneys to serve, provided they complete the appropriate training and receive court approval.

Qualifications and Background

Typically, GALs are attorneys in good standing with demonstrated experience in family law, child advocacy, or guardianship matters. However, individuals who are not attorneys can also be considered if they have completed court-approved training programs. These programs are designed to educate candidates on family dynamics, child development, and the legal responsibilities involved in the GAL role. Regardless of professional background, all GALs must possess knowledge relevant to the emotional and legal complexities that arise in cases involving children or vulnerable individuals.

Court-Approved and Vetted Candidates

Before serving, all prospective Guardians ad Litem must go through a court vetting process, which may include background checks, mandatory training sessions, and registration with the appropriate administrative body. New York courts maintain lists of pre-approved candidates who have completed these requirements. When a judge determines that a GAL is needed, they select from this list to appoint someone qualified, experienced, and impartial.

Commitment to Impartiality

A critical requirement for any GAL is neutrality. As officers of the court, GALs are expected to act without bias and maintain objectivity throughout the legal proceeding. While they are empowered to investigate and advocate for the best interests of the child or incapacitated person, they do not gain any authority over the individual’s personal life, decision-making, or finances outside the boundaries of the case. Their role is strictly limited to gathering relevant facts and advising the court on the most beneficial outcome from the perspective of the individual they represent.

Criteria	Details
Qualifications and Background	Typically attorneys with relevant experience; non-attorneys may qualify with approved training.
Court-Approved and Vetted Candidates	Must complete training, pass background checks, and be on the court’s approved list.
Commitment to Impartiality	Must remain neutral, act in the best interests of the person represented, and have no personal authority.

When and Why Is a Guardian ad Litem Appointed in Family Law Cases?

A Guardian ad Litem (GAL) is not automatically assigned in every New York family law case. Appointment occurs only when the court determines that a child’s welfare might not be fully safeguarded through the ordinary legal process. The decision to appoint a GAL lies solely with the judge, who assesses whether the circumstances justify the need for an independent representative to investigate and advocate for the child’s best interests.

• High-Conflict Custody Disputes: In emotionally charged custody or visitation cases where parents are locked in prolonged disputes, the court may bring in a GAL to provide a neutral and objective voice. When hostility between parents escalates to the point that a child’s needs could be neglected or overshadowed, the GAL steps in to gather information, observe the family dynamics, and ensure the child’s perspective and well-being are factored into any court decisions.
• Allegations of Abuse or Neglect: If there are credible allegations of child abuse, neglect, or exposure to domestic violence, the court often appoints a GAL to conduct an independent investigation. The GAL can speak to school personnel, therapists, medical professionals, and other individuals involved in the child’s life. Their findings help the court determine what safeguards or changes to custody arrangements may be necessary to protect the child from harm.
• Parental Unfitness or Incapacity: When a parent’s ability to care for their child is in question, due to issues such as substance abuse, mental illness, or incarceration, a GAL may be appointed to assess the home environment and each parent’s capacity to provide safe and consistent care. In such situations, the GAL serves as the child’s advocate, especially when the child cannot express their needs or when a parent is unable to adequately represent the child’s interests in court.
• Complex or Special Circumstances: Some custody and visitation matters involve complex family dynamics or unique needs, such as children with disabilities, blended families, or cases where the child’s own preferences may significantly impact the outcome. In these scenarios, the court may rely on a GAL to look deeper into the emotional, educational, and developmental factors that may not be fully addressed through standard legal testimony.
• Request by Parents or Attorneys: In some instances, parents or their attorneys may request a GAL if they believe the involvement of an independent third party would benefit the child. While such requests may influence the judge’s decision, the ultimate authority to appoint a GAL remains with the court. The judge weighs whether the presence of a GAL is necessary based on the best interests of the child and the nature of the issues at hand.

By appointing a GAL when appropriate, New York courts aim to bring greater balance and fairness to family law proceedings, particularly in cases where children are vulnerable to the effects of adult conflict or instability.

Guardian ad Litem in New York Child Custody Cases

One of the most frequent and impactful roles a Guardian ad Litem (GAL) plays is in the context of child custody disputes. These cases often involve emotionally charged dynamics between parents, and the court appoints a GAL to ensure that the child’s well-being remains the central focus throughout the legal process.

Voice for the Child

In many custody proceedings, children do not testify or actively participate in court. The GAL serves as the child’s voice, conveying the child’s thoughts, preferences, and emotional state in a way that is appropriate and developmentally sensitive. 

For children who are old enough and capable of expressing their wishes, the GAL listens and incorporates those views into their report, while carefully evaluating whether those preferences align with the child’s best interests. This representation helps the court understand what the child is experiencing without subjecting them to the stress of direct courtroom involvement.

Neutral Perspective in Conflict

Custody cases often devolve into opposing narratives from each parent, making it difficult for the court to determine what is truly in the child’s best interest. A GAL provides a neutral, fact-based assessment of each parent’s home life, relationship with the child, emotional stability, and ability to meet the child’s needs. Cutting through parental accusations and emotional bias, the GAL presents the court with a clear and objective understanding of the child’s environment and family dynamics. This impartial view helps the court make better-informed decisions based on the child’s overall well-being rather than the volatility of the dispute.

Best Interest Recommendations

After conducting interviews, reviewing records, and observing parent-child interactions, the GAL compiles their findings into a detailed report. This report may include recommendations on:

• Which parent should be awarded primary residential custody
• How parenting time and visitation should be structured
  Whether any conditions should be placed on custody or visitation, such as supervised visits or mandatory parenting education

These recommendations are taken seriously by judges, as they stem from the GAL’s independent investigation and child-centered analysis. While the court is not obligated to follow the GAL’s report, it often plays a pivotal role in the final custody determination.

Reducing Emotional Strain on the Child

Perhaps one of the most valuable functions of a GAL is the ability to shield the child from the adversarial nature of litigation. Rather than placing a child in the stressful position of testifying in court or being forced to choose between parents, the GAL acts as an intermediary. Delivering the child’s perspective through a thoughtful, balanced report, the GAL minimizes the trauma associated with custody proceedings and preserves the child’s sense of stability during a highly disruptive time.

Guardians ad Litem in Adoption and Guardianship Proceedings

While Guardians ad Litem (GALs) are frequently associated with child custody cases, their role extends well beyond divorce-related matters. New York courts also appoint GALs in adoption and guardianship proceedings to ensure that the interests of the most vulnerable parties, children and incapacitated adults, are thoroughly and objectively represented.

GALs in Adoption Cases

In adoption proceedings, especially those involving contested situations or the termination of parental rights, the court may assign a GAL to represent the child’s interests independently of the adopting parties or any birth parents involved. The GAL evaluates whether the adoption serves the child’s long-term welfare, looking at:

• The quality and stability of the proposed adoptive home
• The child’s current relationships and emotional bonds with caretakers
• Any psychological, educational, or developmental needs that must be addressed
• The child’s own preferences, if they are old enough to express them

To gather this information, the GAL may interview the adoptive parents, speak with the child, consult professionals involved in the child’s care, and review relevant records. Based on this investigation, the GAL submits a report with a recommendation on whether the court should approve the adoption. This recommendation is a crucial element in helping the judge decide if the adoption truly promotes the child’s best interests.

GALs in Guardianship of Minors or Incapacitated Persons

In guardianship proceedings, the GAL’s responsibility is to assess the necessity and appropriateness of the guardianship and the fitness of the proposed guardian. This applies in cases involving:

• Minors without active parents (e.g., after the death or incapacitation of both parents)
• Adults with physical or cognitive impairments who may no longer be able to manage their own affairs

For minors, the GAL investigates the petitioning guardian’s background, home environment, and relationship with the child. For adults, especially under New York’s Article 81 guardianship proceedings, the GAL evaluates the alleged incapacitated person’s condition and level of autonomy. The GAL’s duty is to protect the rights of that person and advocate for an outcome that maintains the highest possible quality of life and self-determination, while still meeting their care needs.

How a Guardian ad Litem’s Recommendations Influence Court Decisions

A Guardian ad Litem (GAL) plays a critical advisory role in New York family law cases, particularly when it comes to disputes involving custody, visitation, adoption, or guardianship. While the GAL does not have the legal authority to decide the outcome, their recommendations can significantly shape the direction of a case.

GAL Recommendations Carry Significant Weight

Judges in New York often give considerable deference to a GAL’s report and recommendations. The GAL’s objective findings can provide clarity and help the court focus on the child’s best interests rather than the emotional or strategic arguments presented by either side.

The GAL’s investigative process—interviews, home visits, and document reviews—results in a report that may include suggested custody arrangements, visitation schedules, or safety measures. These recommendations can tip the balance in cases where evidence is otherwise inconclusive or where both parties appear equally capable on the surface.

GAL Input Is Influential, But Not Binding

Although the GAL’s opinions are influential, they are not binding on the court. Judges retain full discretion and will consider the GAL’s recommendations as part of the broader evidentiary record. Alongside the GAL’s report, the judge also evaluates:

• Testimony from parents and other witnesses
• Evidence such as school or medical records
• Psychological evaluations, where applicable
• Legal arguments presented by attorneys

If a judge chooses to diverge from the GAL’s recommendation, they typically provide an explanation on the record. While it’s not unheard of for a court to reach a different conclusion, such a decision usually reflects the presence of strong countervailing evidence.

Judicial Discretion Still Prevails

The ultimate authority in any custody or guardianship matter lies with the judge. For example, if a GAL recommends awarding sole custody to one parent, but the judge finds that both parents are capable of co-parenting effectively, the judge may opt for joint custody instead. In such cases, the judge must weigh the GAL’s concerns against other compelling factors and is expected to explain why they are departing from the GAL’s suggestion, particularly if the recommendation is well-supported.

A Key Factor in Settlement and Strategy

In practice, the GAL’s position often influences case strategy and settlement discussions. Once a GAL’s report is issued, it may signal how the court is likely to lean. As a result, attorneys may encourage clients to consider settlement terms that align with the GAL’s recommendations, especially if continuing litigation may not yield a more favorable outcome. In many cases, parties will adjust their expectations and work toward agreements that reflect the GAL’s input, effectively resolving the case without the need for a trial.

Experienced Legal Guidance from the Law Office of Richard Roman Shum, Esq., PLLC

A Guardian ad Litem can play a vital role in protecting the interests of a child or incapacitated person during emotionally complex legal proceedings. Whether the issue involves custody, guardianship, or adoption, the GAL serves as a neutral voice, helping the court make decisions that prioritize long-term welfare and safety. 

If you are involved in a New York family law matter and have questions about the role of a Guardian ad Litem, reach out to the Law Office of Richard Roman Shum, Esq., PLLC. With compassionate legal support and experience in Manhattan family court, our team is ready to assist you in protecting your rights and advocating for your family’s best interests. Call (646) 259-3416 to schedule a consultation today.

from Law Office of Richard Roman Shum, Esq. https://www.romanshum.com/what-is-a-guardian-ad-litem/

How To Avoid Paying Alimony in New York

Alimony or spousal support is financial assistance provided by a person to their spouse. The amount and frequency of alimony payments are decided by either the couple themselves through negotiations or by a judge who has evaluated the couple’s case.

If you earn more than your spouse, the court may be more likely to assign you the role of “monied spouse,” charged with providing your spouse with alimony. While this is not always the case, having to provide spousal maintenance can prevent you from fully moving on and building a new life after your divorce.

An experienced New York spousal support attorney can help you understand your rights and explore your options to modify your alimony order or potentially terminate payments if your circumstances have changed significantly. At the Law Office of Richard Roman Shum, Esq., skilled New York divorce attorney Richard Shum provides quality legal assistance in spousal support matters and other aspects of divorce. To learn more about how we can assist you in modifying an alimony order, call us today at (646) 259-3416 to schedule a free consultation.

“In both cases attorney Shum was great to work with. Navigating both of these situations was, at times, confusing. Attorney Shum made the details of both matters easy for me to comprehend.”

— Dylan J. (via Avvo.com)

How To Determine Who Qualifies for Spousal Support

In New York, the court usually assigns spousal support depending on the financial capability of each spouse. The court will prioritize giving alimony to a spouse who can demonstrate that they have a financial need for support. The court initially only order alimony on a temporary basis depending on the time the court determines would be enough for the payee spouse to get back on their feet. 

There are three types of alimony in New York:

• Temporary Maintenance (Pendente Lite)
• Post-Divorce Maintenance (Durational)
• Post-Divorce Maintenance (Non-Durational)

Temporary Alimony in New York

Temporary alimony, legally known as temporary maintenance or pendente lite maintenance, lasts for the duration of the divorce proceedings. New York courts apply a statutory formula to calculate the presumptive amount of temporary maintenance. If the court determines the baseline support determined by the calculator to be unjust or inappropriate, a judge can increase or decrease the amount as they see fit.

The formula is based on the payor spouse’s gross annual income, up to $203,000. If the payor earns more than that, the court may consider additional maintenance based on several statutory factors. Temporary alimony does not affect the court’s decision regarding the awarding of post-divorce spousal maintenance.

Temporary alimony ends when the divorce is final or either spouse passes away. Temporary maintenance is separate from post-divorce maintenance. An award of temporary support does not guarantee, nor does it affect, the court’s decision on post-divorce spousal maintenance.

Post-divorce Alimony

Post-divorce alimony or spousal maintenance can either be durational or non-durational. Durational alimony lasts for a fixed amount of time depending on how long the couple has been married:

• 15% – 30% of the time married for couples married for less than or equal to 15 years
• 30% – 40% of the time married for couples married for more than 15 years but less than 20 years
• 35% – 50% of the time married for couples married for more than 20 years

The calculation based on the duration of the marriage can be treated by a judge as a jumping-off point when deciding the duration of alimony. Courts are not required to follow them but often use them unless circumstances justify a deviation.

In addition to marriage length, the court may consider various factors listed under N.Y. Dom. Rel. Law § 236(B)(6)(e) when deciding the duration and amount of spousal maintenance:

• Age and health of each spouse
• Each spouse’s present and future earning capacity
• Any child support award on top of spousal support
• Wasteful or unjust use of marital property
• Whether the spouses were living together before marriage or living separately before the divorce
• Any acts committed by one spouse to the other that prevented them from obtaining meaningful employment such as financial abuse or domestic violence
• Whether the spouses have medical insurance
• Whether a spouse was prevented from continuing a career due to care for children or other family members
• Tax consequences to each spouse
• The couple’s standard of living during the marriage
• Whether a payee spouse gave up or delayed further education or career opportunities in favor of the marriage
• Distribution of marital assets and whether each spouse can get any income from the properties
• Contributions or services of a payee spouse to the payor such as taking care of the household so that the payor can focus on their career
• Any factor the court believes is justifiable to take into consideration

The maintenance formula applies to the payor spouse’s gross income up to $203,000. If the payor earns more than this, the court may award additional support based on the statutory factors. If the court decides that a deviation from the baseline is in order, the new amount will be put in writing including the reasoning and the factors the court used to come to that determination.

A post-divorce maintenance order remains in effect until it reaches its set expiration date, is modified by the court, either spouse dies, or the payee spouse remarries. In some cases, it may be terminated if the payee spouse begins cohabiting with another partner, but only if this condition is outlined in the divorce agreement or court order.

New York spousal support attorney

Permanent Alimony in New York

Permanent alimony, legally referred to as non-durational maintenance, may be awarded in limited situations, typically following a long-term marriage. This type of maintenance is reserved for cases where the payee spouse is unlikely to become financially independent due to factors such as age, health, or extended absence from the workforce. 

The court may award non-durational maintenance under the following circumstances:

• Age – If the payee spouse was not able to support themselves due to stopping their career to take care of the house or children, and they are at an age wherein it would be difficult to reenter the workforce, they may be awarded alimony. Permanent alimony can also be awarded if the judge decides that the assets the payee spouse would get in the divorce would not be enough to support them financially.
• Medical need – If a payee spouse has a severe medical condition or has a disability that prevents them from being self-sufficient, the court can award them permanent alimony.
• Financial dependence – If the payee spouse lacks the education, skills, or work history to achieve financial independence, and the court determines that self-sufficiency is unlikely even with reasonable efforts, permanent alimony may be appropriate.

Non-durational maintenance ends automatically if either spouse dies or if the payee spouse remarries. It may also be modified or terminated upon a substantial change in circumstances, though this is evaluated on a case-by-case basis. Cohabitation with a new partner does not automatically terminate maintenance unless that condition is specifically outlined in the divorce agreement or court order.

“Attorney Richard Shum assisted my family and I with a very difficult landlord. At a time of a lot of concern and uncertainty, Mr. Shum was there for us every inch of the way, his confidence and vast knowledge of the law, together with his passion for it and for helping people, provided us the serenity to go on about our life, while he took care of they daunting matter. At the end we reached an agreement only Atterney Shum could achieve. Since I recommended his service to any friends that is in need of help with legal matters, from Landlord/Tenant to family court, and in every case I receive a thank you call from said friends, following the successful outcome he provided. So, as I say to my friends, if you need an Attorney that will fight for you, and not stress you out, call this guy. you will thank me.”

— Gaby Savransky ( via Google )

How Much Is Alimony in NY

In New York, the amount of alimony, also known as spousal support or maintenance, is primarily determined by specific guidelines set forth by the state. The calculation of alimony is influenced by factors including the income of both parties, the length of the marriage, and the standard of living established during the marriage.

For post-divorce maintenance, New York uses a formula to calculate the suggested amount. This formula considers the income of both the payer and the recipient. Specifically, two calculations are made: one where 20% of the payee’s income is subtracted from 30% of the payer’s income, and another where 40% of the combined income of both spouses is calculated, from which the payee’s income is subtracted. The lower of these two amounts is generally considered the guideline amount for alimony.

It’s important to note that these calculations are subject to a cap on the payer’s income, which is periodically adjusted. As of March 1, 2025, the formula applies to the payor’s gross annual income up to $231,000. If the payor earns more than this amount, the court may consider additional maintenance based on several statutory factors.

Courts may also depart from the guideline amount if applying it would be unjust or inappropriate. Factors the court may consider include the presence of children, health or educational needs, the parties’ respective earning capacities, tax consequences, and the standard of living during the marriage.

While the guideline formula provides a baseline, actual alimony awards can vary. Couples are also free to agree on a different amount through mutual consent. For the most accurate and personalized estimate, it is recommended to consult with an experienced spousal support attorney in New York.

How Is Alimony Paid in New York?

New York courts typically order spousal support to be paid in a monthly fashion. If both spouses agree, they may arrange private payments, such as through direct deposit, without the need for ongoing court involvement. However, when the parties do not agree on the method or schedule of payment, the court may issue an income withholding order, requiring the payor’s employer to deduct the maintenance amount from their wages and send it to the payee.

Should a payor spouse miss payments, the payee spouse can file a formal complaint with the court and request an order to collect the missed payments. 

Lump sum payments of alimony can also be awarded subject to a court order or the spouses’ agreement. Before choosing to pay a lump sum for your alimony payment, you should consider the tax implications of doing so. Your spouse may also remarry before the ordered duration of the alimony payments are due, forfeiting the alimony. Before you make any decisions, it is important to seek the help of an experienced New York spousal support attorney. 

At the Law Office of Richard Roman Shum, Esq., our attorneys work hard to provide quality legal support and representation to clients involved in matters of family law. Our skilled New York spousal support attorneys may be able to guide you through the roles and responsibilities of being a payor spouse in an alimony case. Call us today at (646) 259-3416 to schedule a free consultation.

How To Avoid Paying Alimony

Avoid paying alimony in New York by proving your spouse is self-supporting, negotiating a waiver during the divorce settlement, or showing the marriage was short-term. Courts also consider prenuptial agreements that waive spousal support. Alimony may be denied if the recipient committed acts of financial misconduct.

Paying alimony can be a considerable financial strain to the payor spouse. If the divorce is highly contentious, having to pay spousal support or maintenance may feel like rubbing salt into the wound. However, not paying alimony after being ordered to by the court can result in devastating consequences. 

Approaching the matter of avoiding alimony should be done with careful consideration of the factors surrounding your divorce. There are also some practical and legal methods you can utilize to avoid having to pay spousal support or maintenance in New York.

Creating a Prenuptial or Postnuptial Agreement

A prenuptial agreement can explicitly establish the assets and liabilities each spouse will bring into the marriage. A prenuptial agreement can also include a financial statement from each spouse and lay out exactly which asset belongs to which spouse. 

If you have already finalized your marriage, you can also create a postnuptial agreement. A postnuptial contains essentially the same information as a prenuptial agreement but is created after the marriage.

You should consider having a skilled New York marital agreement attorney draft your documents to make sure they will be enforced by a judge. Having the help of an experienced attorney can ensure that your best interests are protected in the agreement and that it is legally binding.

Give Your Spouse Assets Instead of Spousal Support

If the possibility of creating a prenuptial or a postnuptial agreement is moot due to disagreements with your spouse, you may consider negotiating with your spouse and giving them a larger share of the marital assets, assets that give off income, your marital home, or a bigger chunk of any retirement funds you share. These arrangements are typically formalized in a written settlement agreement and approved by the court.

The court may also decide more favorably on your behalf if you keep friendly communication with your spouse as it shows your willingness to cooperate and negotiate on the specifics of your divorce.

Request a Vocational Evaluation From the Court

If you have reason to believe that your spouse is remaining as a stay-at-home parent even if it is not strictly necessary, you may be able to request the court to conduct a vocational evaluation. A vocational evaluation carefully considers your spouse’s wage-earning capacity and whether they can reenter the workplace with ease after the divorce. 

There is still a chance that the court will require you to pay temporary alimony until the divorce is finalized. While this may feel like a personal offense, especially if the divorce is contentious, it is important to remember that alimony payments are intended to help your spouse get back on their feet and allow themselves to be financially independent. Short-term alimony is a small price to pay, especially if your spouse gave up or postponed career opportunities to help establish your family or advance your career.

“I was very impressed with how astute, detail oriented and methodical Richard is with his work. He is experienced, technically proficient, highly effective and an excellent negotiator, who is proactive and knows the law inside and out. Richard kept me informed regularly and was responsive to all my requests and queries. All the traits that any good lawyer worth his salt should possess.”

— Private Client (via Avvo.com)

Submit Proof That Your Spouse Does Not Require Spousal Maintenance

If your spouse has access to sufficient financial resources, such as substantial savings, a trust, or other income, it may reduce their eligibility for spousal maintenance. Providing full financial disclosures and supporting documentation can help demonstrate that your spouse is not financially dependent.

Courts assess maintenance based on need and ability to pay, not on personal motives. Demonstrating that your spouse has the resources to maintain a similar standard of living can influence the court’s decision.

Reduce Your Spending Where Possible

Given that getting a divorce can be a financially intensive process, it’s likely that you have already made a lot of lifestyle changes to accommodate that cost. It may be a good idea to evaluate your expenses, making sure to live within your means. If your spouse petitions the court for alimony, your monthly expenses and income will be among the factors considered by the judge in determining whether to award spousal support or maintenance.

Another important factor to consider is to never waste marital assets while in the process of finalizing your divorce. While you may feel like it is within your right to spend your marital funds as a result of the divorce, financially irresponsible acts can count as a demerit against you when the court is evaluating whether to award alimony to your spouse.

File Your Divorce Sooner Rather Than Later

In New York, the length of the marriage is a factor in determining how long post-divorce maintenance should last. The court typically measures the marriage length from the date of the wedding to the date the divorce action is filed and not the date it is finalized. Filing earlier may result in a shorter marriage duration, which can reduce the length of potential maintenance payments.

Stay Informed About Your Spouse’s Relationships

You will no longer be required to pay spousal maintenance if your ex-spouse has remarried. If your former spouse is cohabiting with a new partner, maintenance may end only if the divorce agreement or court order specifically includes that condition. Cohabitation alone does not automatically terminate maintenance under New York law. You should get the advice of your New York divorce attorney to determine whether you are required to continue paying spousal maintenance after your ex-spouse has begun living together with a new partner.

File a Fault Divorce

New York allows for fault-based divorces on grounds such as adultery or cruel and inhuman treatment. If the court finds that one spouse’s misconduct was egregious and directly contributed to the breakdown of the marriage, it may take that behavior into account when deciding whether to award maintenance. You will need to provide proof of the wrongdoing to support your claim. The judge will also be the one to decide whether the fault-based grounds for the divorce have merit.

Working with an experienced New York contested divorce attorney who can protect your best interests and help you understand your rights under the law is essential. New York contested divorce attorney Richard Shum may be able to walk you through the process of filing a fault-based divorce. Our attorneys at the Law Office of Richard Roman Shum, Esq provide quality legal counsel and aggressive representation in the interest of protecting our clients’ rights. Call us today at (646) 259-3416 to schedule a free consultation.

Method to Avoid Paying Alimony	Description
Prenuptial or Postnuptial Agreement	Establishing legal agreements before or after marriage to define asset ownership and exclude alimony payments.
Giving Spouse Assets Instead	Negotiating with your spouse to provide a larger share of marital assets, income-generating assets, or retirement funds as an alternative to alimony.
Requesting Vocational Evaluation	Requesting a court-conducted evaluation of your spouse’s wage-earning capacity to determine their ability to reenter the workforce after the divorce.
Submitting Proof of No Financial Need	Seeking legal assistance to declare complete financial statements, proving that your spouse doesn’t require spousal maintenance for their standard of living.
Reducing Personal Spending	Evaluating expenses and living within your means, considering that your expenses and income may be factors considered by the court in determining alimony.
Filing for Divorce Sooner	Initiating divorce proceedings promptly to potentially minimize the duration of alimony payments based on the length of the marriage.
Staying Informed About Spouse’s Status	Monitoring your ex-spouse’s remarriage or cohabitation with a new partner, which may impact the requirement for spousal maintenance.
Filing a Fault Divorce	Pursuing a fault divorce by providing evidence of spousal abuse or adultery to reduce the chances of your spouse being awarded alimony.

Limit the Duration of Spousal Support Through Negotiation

When facing divorce proceedings, one critical aspect that often arises is the issue of spousal support, commonly known as alimony. In New York, the duration and amount of spousal support can significantly impact both parties’ financial futures. However, it is possible to limit the duration of spousal support through careful negotiation during the divorce settlement process.

New York law provides guidelines for calculating both temporary and post-divorce spousal maintenance, taking into account factors such as the length of the marriage, the age and health of the parties, present and future earning capacities, and the need for one party to incur education or training expenses. However, these laws also allow for flexibility if both parties agree to different terms during negotiations. This kind of negotiation is often honored by the court and incorporated into the final judgment, offering both parties more control over their financial futures.

To avoid indefinite alimony obligations, you and your attorney can negotiate a specific end date or set a duration cap for spousal support as part of your divorce agreement. This approach not only clarifies the financial obligations for both parties but also provides a clearer path towards financial independence post-divorce.

Finalizing a spousal support agreement with a defined termination point can be beneficial. It removes uncertainties and allows both individuals to plan their finances more effectively. It is important to have these discussions and come to an agreement while the divorce process is ongoing. Once the court finalizes the divorce decree, modifying the terms of spousal support can be more challenging and require proving a significant change in circumstances.

Working with a knowledgeable attorney to negotiate these terms effectively can lead to a fair and definitive spousal support arrangement, preventing lingering financial ties and fostering a smoother transition into post-divorce life.

How Moving Out of State May Impact Alimony

Moving out of New York after a divorce does not automatically eliminate or reduce a court-ordered spousal maintenance obligation. However, in certain cases, relocation may be considered a substantial change in circumstances, which could provide grounds to request a modification of the existing spousal support order.

If the relocation is initiated by the spouse paying support or the one receiving it, the outcome depends on several factors. These include how the move affects income, living expenses, or employability, and whether any terms about relocation were included in the Marital Settlement Agreement (MSA). If relocation is anticipated, it is advisable to address it within the MSA to avoid future disputes.

It is also important to note that a New York spousal support order remains legally enforceable in other states under the Uniform Interstate Family Support Act (UIFSA). Relocating to another state does not remove the obligation to pay unless the court formally modifies the order.

If you are considering relocating to another state after a divorce, it is prudent to proactively amend your divorce arrangements to address potential changes. This enables you to make informed choices regarding your financial situation, tailored to your unique circumstances. This highlights the importance of consulting with an attorney before making any significant adjustments to your post-divorce arrangements.

Considering a move out of state to avoid alimony can have significant legal implications, and it’s crucial to handle this matter with the guidance of a seasoned New York spousal support attorney. At the Law Office of Richard Roman Shum, Esq., our experienced lawyers understand the nuances of alimony laws in New York and can provide strategic guidance to help you make informed decisions about your case. Contact us to schedule a consultation and gain insight into your alimony concerns.

Can a Working Wife Get Alimony?

In New York, a working wife may be eligible for alimony if the court determines that she requires financial support. Alimony, also known as spousal support, is intended to help balance economic differences between spouses after divorce. It may assist the lower-earning spouse in maintaining a standard of living similar to that established during the marriage or support their transition to financial independence.

The amount and duration of maintenance are determined by a range of factors, including each spouse’s income and earning potential, the length of the marriage, and the recipient’s financial needs. Employment alone does not prevent a spouse from receiving support if the court finds that their income is not enough to meet their reasonable needs.

How Do I Modify an Alimony Order or Stop Paying if I Have Already Been Ordered by the Court?

The main purpose of alimony and spousal maintenance is to help your spouse get back on their feet after a divorce. In most cases, awarding alimony is not meant to be a punishment to the payor spouse. If your circumstances have significantly changed since the court issued the original maintenance order, you may petition the court to modify or terminate the obligation.

Courts may consider a modification request if there has been a substantial change in circumstances, such as:

• You experience financial hardship as a result of a lifestyle change
  • You retire
  • You lose your job or make less money than you did before the divorce was finalized
• Your spouse has gotten a job and become financially independent 
• Your spouse remarries
• You contract an illness or sustain a disability that keeps you from working

These grounds may be useful, especially if the court has awarded permanent alimony to your spouse. However, if your financial hardship is self-induced, meaning you quit your job and became unemployed just to avoid paying alimony, the court may disregard your petition and order you to continue paying the same amount of spousal support or maintenance.

To pursue a modification, you must file a formal petition with the court that issued the original order and be prepared to present documentation supporting your claim. A hearing is typically required.

“Most kind and professional lawyer. A true gift. He saved me from the brutal claw of my management company and saved me a lot of money and pain.”

— Shira Arad ( via Google )

Get the Help of an Experienced New York Spousal Support Attorney

Stopping the payment of alimony out of the blue can have enormous legal repercussions. Without a valid reason and without following the appropriate legal processes to modify your spousal support order, the court can order your wages to be garnished and use it to pay your outstanding payments. Any tax refund you receive may also be seized to pay for spousal support. In the worst-case scenario, a judge can hold you in contempt of court and sentence you to jail.

Richard Shum, a top-rated New York spousal support attorney, may be able to help you petition a modification of your spousal support order. At the Law Office of Richard Roman Shum, Esq., we understand the importance of being able to start anew after a divorce. This can be challenging if you are experiencing a financial strain in the form of having to pay spousal support.

Our skilled attorneys can help determine the legal options available for you to avoid paying a large amount of money for alimony or avoid paying it entirely. To schedule a complimentary consultation with one of our experienced New York spousal support attorneys, contact us today at (646) 259-3416.

from Law Office of Richard Roman Shum, Esq. https://www.romanshum.com/blog/how-to-avoid-paying-alimony-in-new-york/

Is New York a Community Property State for Divorce?

When couples decide to divorce, one of the most important considerations is the division of assets and debts. While some states, like California, follow community property laws that require a 50/50 split of marital property, New York operates under a different set of laws when it comes to property division in a divorce.

In New York, marital property is divided based on the principle of equitable distribution. This means that property acquired during the marriage will be divided in a way that is fair and equitable, but not necessarily equal. The court will consider a variety of factors when making its decision, including the length of the marriage, the income and earning potential of each spouse, and the contributions made by each spouse to the marriage.

Navigating property division in a divorce can be challenging. Ensure your rights are protected and you receive a fair distribution of assets with the help of an experienced New York divorce lawyer. At the Law Office of Richard Roman Shum, Esq., our team of skilled Manhattan divorce lawyers can guide you through the divorce process in New York and advocate for your best interests. Call us today at (646) 259-3416 to schedule a consultation.

Is New York a Community Property State for Divorce?

New York is not a community property state for divorce. Instead, it follows an equitable distribution model, meaning marital property is divided fairly but not necessarily equally. The court considers factors like income, length of marriage, and contributions of each spouse when dividing assets.

Equitable Distribution States

Equitable distribution is a legal concept that outlines the procedure for dividing marital assets and debts when a couple undergoes divorce. Despite its name, equitable distribution does not necessarily require an equal split of all marital property. Instead, the court takes into account a range of factors pertaining to the marriage and the contributions of each spouse. The court possesses significant discretion in determining how assets are allocated, with the primary objective of allocating the assets fairly rather than uniformly.

Before the transition to equitable distribution in New York, the state-operated under a common law property system. Under this system, the allocation of property in divorce cases was based solely on the name listed as the titleholder. If a property had one spouse’s name on the title, they were the sole rightful owner of that asset. However, New York now functions as an equitable distribution state, whereby the division of property in divorce proceedings is conducted with the aim of achieving fairness and justice for both parties involved.

In the United States, the majority of states follow the equitable distribution when it comes to property division in divorce cases, although exceptions exist in the form of community property states. The states that follow community property include Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, New Mexico, Texas, Washington, and Wisconsin, along with Puerto Rico, which also follows community property principles. In Alaska, there is a unique provision where couples have the option to choose whether their property will be considered as community property. This means that couples in Alaska can decide whether to follow the community property system or opt for another arrangement when it comes to the division of their assets in the event of a divorce. 

Seeking a fair and equitable resolution in a divorce case can be challenging, especially in equitable distribution states like New York. At the Law Office of Richard Roman Shum, Esq., our experienced New York divorce attorneys can help you manage the process and ensure that your assets are distributed fairly. We have a deep understanding of New York’s equitable distribution laws and are committed to protecting your rights and achieving a favorable resolution. Contact us today to schedule a consultation and take the first step toward a brighter future.

How are Assets Split in a Divorce in NY?

In New York, the division of assets during a divorce is governed by a principle known as equitable distribution. This method does not automatically split assets 50/50 but instead aims to divide them in a manner that is fair to both parties, considering the unique details of the marriage and subsequent separation.

To determine what is equitable, courts consider numerous factors, including the financial status of each spouse both when they married and when they are divorcing. The length of the marriage, as well as the age and health of both spouses, are also significant considerations. Any children from the marriage are given special attention, with a focus on providing for their needs, such as enabling the custodial parent to keep the family home and maintain the children’s standard of living.

The court also examines how the divorce will affect each spouse’s financial future. This includes assessing the potential loss of inheritance, pension rights, and health insurance benefits. Contributions that one spouse made to the other’s career or earning potential, such as supporting a spouse through school or managing the household, are taken into account, as are contributions to the acquisition or improvement of marital property.

Challenges that arise in appraising certain assets, like a business, are carefully weighed, along with the tax consequences of the divorce. The court takes a particularly dim view of any wasteful dissipation or deliberate undervaluing of marital assets by either party.

When a straightforward division of assets is not feasible, the court may order a distributive award. This monetary award is designed to compensate for assets that cannot be split physically, ensuring that the financial settlement is equitable, taking into account the intricacies of the couple’s financial life together and the reality of their divorce.

How Are Marital Debts Divided in New York?

Marital debts in New York are divided based on the principle of equitable distribution. Courts consider factors like income, length of the marriage, and each spouse’s financial contributions. Only debts incurred during the marriage and for marital purposes are typically divided, while personal debts remain separate.

Commingled Property and Asset Division in New York Divorce

When couples in New York decide to divorce, the division of property can become a central issue, especially when dealing with commingled assets. Commingled property refers to assets that were originally separate property of one spouse but have been mixed or combined with marital property during the marriage. This blending can make the original separate property subject to division in a divorce. New York follows equitable distribution rules, meaning that property is divided fairly, though not always equally.

Separate property typically includes assets such as an inheritance, a gift from a third party, or property owned before the marriage. However, if those assets are commingled—for example, if inherited funds are deposited into a joint bank account and used for shared expenses—they may be reclassified as marital property. Similarly, if one spouse owned a home prior to the marriage and the other contributed to renovations or paid toward the mortgage, the increase in the home’s value may be subject to division. 

In some cases, it may be possible to trace the original separate asset through financial records. If successful, courts may consider maintaining its separate status, at least in part. However, tracing can be challenging, and the burden of proof typically falls on the spouse claiming the asset as separate.

Divorcing spouses should maintain clear records of their assets and how those assets were used or combined during the marriage. This documentation can be crucial in determining how assets should be divided. Courts in New York will carefully review the nature of commingled assets and make decisions based on fairness to both parties.

Domestic Relations Law and Equitable Distribution

The New York Domestic Relations Law sets out the rules for the division of marital property in divorce cases. Section 236(B)(5)(d) of the Domestic Relations Law provides that marital property is to be divided based on the principle of equitable distribution. The law defines marital property as any property acquired by either spouse during the marriage, regardless of how the property is titled or held.

The Domestic Relations Law also allows for separate property to be protected from division in a divorce. Separate property is property that is acquired by one spouse before the marriage, or property that is acquired by gift, inheritance, or personal injury award during the marriage. However, if separate property is commingled with marital property, it may lose its status as separate property and become subject to division in a divorce.

The Domestic Relations Law sets forth the factors that courts consider when dividing marital property in a divorce. These factors include:

• The income and property of each spouse at the time of marriage and at the time of the divorce
• The length of the marriage and the age and health of the spouses
• The need of the custodial parent to occupy or own the marital residence and to use or own its household effects
• The loss of inheritance and pension rights upon dissolution of the marriage as of the date of dissolution
• Any equitable claim to, interest in, or direct or indirect contribution made to the acquisition of such marital property by the party not having a title, including joint efforts or expenditures and contributions and services as a spouse, parent, wage earner, and homemaker, and to the career or career potential of the other party.

Factor	Description
Income and Property	Compares what each spouse owned at the time of marriage vs. at divorce
Length of Marriage & Health	Assesses how long the marriage lasted and the spouses’ age and physical condition
Custodial Parent’s Housing Needs	Reviews whether the custodial parent should remain in the marital home
Loss of Inheritance & Pension Rights	Accounts for rights lost due to divorce finalization
Contributions to Marital Property	Considers homemaking, parenting, or career support contributions

Case Law and Equitable Distribution

The New York courts have issued numerous decisions that provide guidance on how to apply the principle of equitable distribution in divorce cases. In the case of Grunfeld v. Grunfeld, the court emphasized that equitable distribution does not mean equal distribution and that the goal is to arrive at a result that is fair and reasonable under the circumstances of the case. Grunfeld v Grunfeld, 255 AD2d 12, 21 [1st Dept 1999]

In another case, Majauskas v. Majauskas, the court established the principle that pension benefits earned during the marriage are marital property subject to division in a divorce. This decision has had significant implications for the division of retirement benefits in divorce cases. Majauskas v Majauskas, 61 NY2d 481, 486 [1984]

While New York is not a community property state, the division of marital property in divorce cases is still an important issue. If you are facing a divorce and are concerned about the division of your assets, it is important to work with an experienced family law attorney who can help you understand your legal rights and options.

Familiarity with the principles of equitable distribution and New York’s rules on dividing marital property can help you face the divorce process more effectively and protect your financial interests. At the Law Office of Richard Roman Shum, Esq., we offer experienced, quality legal assistance and services aimed at helping New Yorkers in divorce and family law cases. Contact us today at (646) 259-3416 to schedule a consultation.

from Law Office of Richard Roman Shum, Esq. https://www.romanshum.com/blog/is-new-york-a-community-property-state-for-divorce/